Fake forward emails will obliterate your customer’s trust

The other day I got an email from someone whose email list I’m subscribed to. The subject line looked like:

Fwd: bonus business workshop (regularly $495)

Since I forward emails from clients and business contacts regularly, I opened it up to see what it was about. I wasn’t aware of any business workshop I missed.

About 10 seconds in I realized that I was suckered into opening that email.

It contained a straight-up sales pitch from the sender’s friend. The friend was adding their product to the senders product as a limited time bonus.

What followed was a sales letter with all the gimmicks.

Scarcity.

Expiration.

Countdown image.

Bold text in every paragraph.

The only things missing where "Dear friend" and the yellow highlight.

I’m not sure which was faster…

  1. The demolishing of trust I had in the sender,
  2. Or how quickly I unsubscribed and blacklisted them from emailing me again.

I think the trust evaporation might have been a bit faster. But it was one of those "which falls faster, a pound of iron or a pound of feathers?"

What makes it even worse was that I was a customer of theirs for about two years and spent several hundred dollars with them already.

That’s how fast you can lose a customer when you abuse their trust. The sender doesn’t even know this happened and I’m not going to tell them.

Sure they probably got a great open rate on that email. Probably a high click rate too since the unsubscribe link counts as a click.

But by tricking their subscribers with that subject line and fooling them, they insulted their entire subscriber base.

It will probably take at least 6 months to repair. Maybe upwards of a year or two.

You can avoid a misstep like this one if you remember to keep your customers in mind and remember what it feels like to be on their side.

For example emailing a repeat customer about your "new customer discount" is going to piss them off and make them an ex-customer. Same as trying to trick your customers into opening your email.

You really need to understand the behavior of your customers to avoid mistakes like that. Repeat Customer Insights can help you understand the larger buying behavior of your customers.

Eric Davis

Are you struggling to grow your repeat purchases? Get help deciding where to optimize your store for retention and repeat customer purchases.

You'll learn about:
  • Why your repeat purchase rate is an excellent measure of your future success
  • How to calculate your repeat purchase rate and average order values
  • Why defining the path of your ideal customer can help you evaluate marketing and retention tactics
  • Why focusing on repeat customers can have an out-sized ROI impact on your revenue
If you're wanting to learn how to guide your retention decisions with metrics and data, this will give you the knowledge and tools that make that happen (and boost your revenue at the same time).